NBI at Sidi Kaouki

A dozen NBI has been spotted by the coast of Sidi Kaouki, South of Essaouira during several weeks last February. Sylvie Brignon, provided us the information and the pictures.

This is the biggest group recorded outside the known breeding and wintering area around Massa and Tamri.

Photo, Sylvie Brignon

The furthermost location of Aylal has been by the Commune Tafedna, some 70 km Norht of Tamri, and juveniles are often seen by Imsouane, 20 km North of Tamri. This new location at Sidi Kaouki is 140 km as the crow flies from this breeding site.

Photo, Sylvie Brignon

Lire en français

2013 breeding results

I. Introduction:

In the framework of the National Species Action Plan for Northern Bald Ibis, Geronticus eremita, prepared in 2008 by HCEFLCD (High Commission for Water and Forest and Fight against Desertification) with its partners, monitoring NBI is one of the main aspects to follow population dynamics. Collected data are essential to take any decision to manage the last viable NBI population in the world. 

II. Main activities and events in  2013

1. Wardens

Seven wardens are recruited with the cooperation of Prince Albert II of Monaco Foundation, 4 in Souss Massa National Park and 3 in Tamri area. 

2. Site C
Dummies installed at site C faded and are currently dusty. They are not efficient and should be retired.

3. Disturbance

Breeding sites didn't suffer too much disturbance by tourist, compared to previous years. 12 visitors, 9 of them birders, approached Tamri site and two photographers went close to sites A and F, in the Park. 

Nevertheless, this year site E was very frequented by fishermen just at the beginning of the breeding season. Wardens, assisted by rangers kindly persuaded the fishermen to leave.

4. Waterpoints
Waterpoints are daily cleaned and filled with fresh water by the wardens, during all the breeding season. Their monitoring showed a regular use by adults and, later, fledgings.

See here to know more about water supply

III. 2013 breeding season results 

Breeding season started in Tamri by the first week of February and finissed during the last week of Mai. Unlike the previous year, in 2013 60 pairs produced fledgings from 161 hatchlings. Although survival is relatively low (44%), productivity (1,1 fledgling/nest) is satisfactory. 
In SMNP breeding started later, by the first week of March, and finished in mid June. A lanner falcon prevented ibises to nest at site B (that usually holds 6 pairs), thus only 53 pairs nested and 77 fledging survived from 101 hatchings (survival 76%; productivity, 1,4 fledgling/nest). 
Altogether, 118 pairs were formed, 113 nested successfully and produced 262 chicks 148 of whom fledgled (survival rate, 56%, productivity, 1,3 fledgling/nest). 

Table 1. Results at the different sites.

Parameters	SMNP					TAMRI	PNSM & TAMRI
	Site A	Site B	Site F	Site E	Total
Formed pairs	20	0	16	20	56	62	118
Laying pairs  (1)	20	0	15	18	53	60	113
Hatchlings	34	0	34	33	101	161	262
Fledglings (2)	28	0	24	25	77	71	148
Survival rate  (%)	82,3	0	70,5	75,7	76,2	44	56,4
Productivity (2/1)	1,4	0	1,6	1,3	1,4	1,1	1,3

Differences with 2012 (Table 2) are due to the good weather conditions, with rains well distributed between September 2012 and April 2013. 

Table 2. Comparaison between 2012 and 2013

Parameter	SMNP		Tamri		SMNP &Tamri
	2012	2013	2012	2013	2012	2013
Formed pairs	62	56	43	62	105	118
Laying pairs (1)	54	53	11	60	65	113
Hatchlings	95	101	0	161	95	262
Fledglings  (2)	56	77	0	71	56	148
Productivity (2/1)	1	1.4	0	1.1	0.8	1.3

The number of pairs is the highest since the creation of the Park (Figure 1).

Figure 1 : Evolution of number of NBI breeding pairs in Souss-Massa region

The number of chicks produced also increased (Figure 2), despite the relatively low survival rates observed in Tamri site, and it's one of the highest even recorded.  This mortality could be explained, among other things, by a shortness of food resources available in a region in which there is more disturbance from human activities (tourism development, nomadic herds, ...).

Figure 2 : Evolution of productivity of NBI population in Souss-Massa region (blue, number of fledglings; red, productivity)

Regular census shows that before breeding there were 319 individuals. After breeding, the number rose to 443 birds (Figure 3) .

Figure 3: Evolution of NBI population at Souss-Massa region before (blue) and after (pink) breeding

The gap between both figures some years reachs more than 100, meaning that a number of birds disperses outside the prospected area. 

It's worth to note that just after breeding, most ibis from Tamri region move to the limits of Souss-Massa National Park. In 2012 this displacement occurred even before, due to the failure of breeding at Tamri (Figure 4).

Figure 4: Monitoring of NBI numbers between 2011 and 2013

SMNP role is essential for the survival of the species. 

IV. Conclusion

NBI had a good breeding season, with a record of 113 breeding pairs, 148 fledglings and a rate of 1,3 fledgling/nest.

After this breeding season, the whole population at Souss-Massa region  has been evaluated at 443. 

After the original report by :

Widade OUBROU & Mohammed El Bekkay

Kelaynack flies south

(from BirdLife Community)

Following a successful breeding season for the semi-wild Northern Bald Ibis population at Birecik, Turkey, six of the birds were released as part of trial re-introductions work in late July. A dedicated team first caught up all the birds for the annual ringing/check of the birds at the Birecik ‘Kelaynak’ breeding station run by the Turkish Ministry of Nature Protection and National Parks, and six were selected for release in the hope that they would survive and migrate. Three were fitted with satellite transmitters, and to reduce the chance of persecution, their bright rings were replaced with much less conspicuous ones. Four of the birds were 2013 juveniles, and in addition, two one-year old birds were also released.

For the first two weeks, the birds remained very close to the breeding station, feeding at a number of local sites in the area, as well as taking supplementary food provided. This week, however, excitement mounts as five of the birds have departed south, and the intriguing news is that they have stopped off very close to Palmyra in Syria, where the remaining wild population there has this year sadly declined to just one individual.

Whether the birds will stay in the area or continue their ‘migration’ further south, we will find out from the satellite signals. The work was recommended as a priority at last year’s inaugural meeting of the AEWA International Working Group for Northern Bald Ibis, held at Jazan in Saudi Arabia and by the International Advisory Group for Northern Bald Ibis. Several partners are involved in the work in addition to the Turkish Ministry, with satellite tags provided by Doğa Derneği (BirdLife in Turkey), with Prince Albert II of Monaco Foundation and RSPB (BirdLife in the UK) support.

This news is brought to you by the BirdLife Preventing Extinctions Programme

NBI and people

Teo Todorov took this beautiful picture of some NBI searching for food in the southern part of Souss Massa National Park in April, 2009.

This kind of sights is easy to observe in SMNP and surroundings, where NBI frequent cultures, fallows and pasture lands, not far from people.

Breeding finish at Tamri

Aylal has left the colony on May 15^th. It has been around Tamri since the beginning of February.

It’s installed in the central part of SMNP. The colonies in the Park have still chicks due to the gap between nesting in Tamri and in Massa.

Mild winter and wet spring have probably contributed to the earlier beginning of the breeding season.

Last Northern Bald Ibis in Syria?

The events in Syria fill us with great sadness and grief. In spite of the crisis, the local team has continued to monitor the ibis, and has reported the sad news that only one of the Northern Bald Ibis has returned to the breeding site at Palmyra this spring. Unfortunately, there are no signs of any more birds so far returning from their migration to Ethiopia. The returning female Zenobia was last year paired to Odeinat, the last male, which was fitted with a small satellite tag that stopped transmitting in southern Saudi Arabia in July 2012. It has not been possible to search for Odeinat, as the last signals did not give an accurate location. Subsequently, a total of four birds was seen briefly in January this year by Yilma Abebe and Tariku Dagne (a visit supported by the Ethiopian Natural History Society and the Culture and Tourism Office of Ethiopia, with funds from RSPB) at the usual Ethiopian highland wintering site, but it now seems clear that only one of these birds has returned to the breeding area.

Last Syrian ibis among bedouin khaimahs 
(Photo M.S. Abdallah)

This looks ominously like it may be the end for the relict eastern population of the species, having been rediscovered in 2002 when there were 3 breeding pairs. Despite huge efforts the colony dwindled to just one pair in the past two years and now it seems to just the one bird. This comes at a time when coordinated efforts are strengthening and indeed after the establishment of the new International Working Group was held in Jazan, Saudi Arabia in November 2012.

Among the hopes for maintaining the eastern population are further releases from the former colony site at Birecik in SE Turkey where a semi-wild population persists.


Historical note:
Zenobia was the last empress of Palmyra, Odeinat's widow, who, after expanding his kingdom to Egypt and Anatolia, was defeated and captured by Aurelian in 272.

Sexual dimorphism

As in most waders, sexes in NBI are similar in plumage, although males are generally larger than females. For instance, males have slightly longer wings than females (403-420 vs. 390-408 mm). As with other ibises that breed in colonies, males have also longer beaks.

Photo Brian Stone

Babbitt et al. (2007) made an analysis of sexual dimorphism in ibises. Using all 16 species for which sufficient data were available, they found that the degree of sexual dimorphism in proportional bill length was positively associated with the incidence of colonial breeding (r = 0.68, P = 0.005). On the other hand, the degree of sexual dimorphism in proportion to bill length was not significantly associated with the incidence of group foraging (r = 0.36, P = 0.18). The incidence of colonial nesting and group foraging were correlated (r = 0.55, P = 0.03) with each other, but not as strongly as the degree of sexual bill length dimorphism and colonial breeding. That means that males of gregarious breeding ibis species, like NBI, tend to have longer bills than females.
Size matters: Longer-billed males are more successful in attracting a mate.

Regarding the differences between the two populations, NBI have longer bills in Morocco than in Turkey. There's not a known reason for that, but the sexual dimorphism still exists in both populations.

Population	Male bill length	Female bill length
Morocco	141.1 mm (5.55 in)	133.5 mm (5.25 in)
Turkey	129.0 mm (5.08 in)	123.6 mm (4.87 in)

Nevertheless, the difference is very small, about 5%, to be realised in the field.

References
Babbitt, Gregory A.; Frederick & Peter C. (2007). Selection for sexual bill dimorphism in ibises: an evaluation of hypotheses. Waterbirds 30 (2): 199–206.
Siegfried, W.R. (1972). Discrete breeding and wintering areas of the Waldrapp Geronticus eremita (L.). Bulletin of the British Ornithologists' Club 92: 102–103.
Brown, L. H., Urban, E. K., & Newman, K. (1982). The birds of Africa. Vol I.

NBI and people

Northern Bald Ibis have had an important role in human culture. In addition to the religious and symbolic meaning for ancient Egyptians, in other places where it has existed has also been considered in many senses, as in Algeria. This is probably due to the behaviour of the species, which could be quite tame to people.

In Souss Massa National Park, coexistence between NBI and people has been exemplary, permiting the bird to survive in this region in spite of its extinction anywhere else.

Sidi Wassay is a village besides oued Massa stuary and was among the first to cooperate with the Park and SEO/BirdLife in the implementation of human and economical development. Thus, many women received primary education and the first group of beekeepers was also organised managing a comunal apiary sharing 40 hives (see more about this cooperation in Spanish or French)


Furthermore, Sidi Wassay is a place where NBI is quite easy to observe, due to high quality feeding grounds and its strategic situation inside the National Park. These are, maybe, the reason to choose this bird as a mascot by the Sahel Sidi Wassay Association for Cooperation and Development and the Chabab Sport Club.

On the tower of a guesthouse at Massa (photo Gianni Conca & Bruna Morandotti)

Image by Otto Kleinschmidt in 
Naturgeschichte der Vögel Mitteleuropas 
by Johann Andreas NAUMANN, 1899 
showing two NBI on a masonry wall. 

Some authors explain how the species used to nest on towers and ruins, but also that their ckicks were a delicacy for epicures. Fledglings are abundant on early representations of NBI, probably showing a familiarity to young birds kept in captivity for human consumption. 

In fact, among the first text talking about the species in early 16th century, there are several decrees punishing the capture of this species, reflecting the importance of this prosecution in Europe.
Eleazar Albin writes in the 18th century they build for the moſt part in high Walls of demoliſhed or ruinous Towers which are common in Switzerland and later The young ones are commended for good Meat and county a Dainty; their Fleſh is ſweet and their Bones tender and, later, ... deſert places; where they build in Rocks and old forſaken Towers.

Monument to kelaynak, Birecik

On the other side, the Turkish town of Bireçik held about 500 pairs by the middle of last century and reached an estimated total population of about 3,000 around 1930. NBI was higly regarded by people there, due to the myth of Noah and several religious beliefs. According to the local legend, Noah released kelaynak, the bald ibis, who leads the Ark to a place where they were established.

Old colony over Bireçik,

in the 1950s

It was also believed that the ibis migrated to the South each year to guide Hajj pilgrims to Mecca. A festival was held annually to celebrate its return north, also as a symbol of spring.
By the 1970s, the urban development and the loose of traditions led to the deterioriation of the colony and pesticides contribute to the decline.

NBI nestig besides white storks at Aït Benhaddou.
Why such  a diferent fate?

Although we don't know a particular mithological or legendary status on Northern Bald Ibis in Moroccan traditions, there are records of colonies on emblematic buildings.
There was a small colony on some ksours (adobe fortified houses) in Aït Benhaddou, as shown in the documentary French  The Oued. Those nests were apparently removed in the 1970s when the old buildings where mended for a film shooting.

Currently, the two surviving population are still quite tame. Although they seek for quite and inaccessible sites for nesting, when looking for food they are more confident. It's possible that insects are more abundant close to humane shettlements due to home refuses or livestock dung.

 NBI among besouin haimas in Syria (Photo M.S. Abdallah)

 A similar image in an Ethiopia village (Photo Gianluca Serra)

... and in Vejer, Andalusia, from Proyecto eremita (Photo Paco Vera)

Prince Albert II of Monaco Foundation renews its engagement to NBI conservation

Prince Albert II of Monaco Foundation, which is the species champion for Northern Bald Ibis, has renewed its conmitment towards the conservation of one of the most endangered birds in the world.

PA2MF has been funding mainly the wardens' expenditures (salaries and equipment), as well as other functioning costs. This is essential to the monitoring and surveillance in the colonies, and allow us to know about their behaviour, how they use their range or what are their breeding performances.

With this contribution, PA2MF is one of the most important partners for the conservation of this critically endangered species both the Moroccan and the eastern population.

Akh: NBI from Ancient Egypt

A couple of recent articles on NBI from Ancient Egypt, from the UCLA Encyclopedia of Egyptology.

Janák, Jíří. (2013). Northern Bald Ibis (Akh-Bird). UCLA Encyclopedia of Egyptology, 1(1). nelc_uee_8788.

Three different kinds of ibis species are attested from ancient Egypt: the sacred ibis, the glossy ibis, and the northern bald ibis. Pictorial representations of the latter bird—easily recognizable by the shape of its body, the shorter legs, long curved beak, and the typical crest covering the back of the head—were used in writings of the noun akh and related words and notions (e.g., the blessed dead). We can deduce from modern observations that in ancient times this member of the ibis species used to dwell on rocky cliffs on the eastern bank of the Nile, that is, at the very place designated as the ideal rebirth and resurrection region (the akhet). Thus, the northern bald ibises might have been viewed as visitors and messengers from the other world—earthly manifestations of the blessed dead (the akhu). 

The material and pictorial evidence dealing with the northern bald ibis in ancient Egypt is accurate, precise, and elaborate in the early periods of Egyptian history (until the final phase of the third millennium BCE). Later, the representations of this bird became schematized and do not correspond to nature. Thus, they do not present us with any direct and convincing evidence for the presence of the northern bald ibis in Egypt, and, moreover, they most probably witness both the bird’s decline and its disappearance from the country.

Janák, Jíří. (2013). Akh. UCLA Encyclopedia of Egyptology, 1(1). nelc_uee_8790. 

The notion of akh, often translated as (effective) spirit, pointed toward many different meanings, such as the identity of the transfigured dead as well as that of living persons who acted efficaciously for (or on behalf of) their masters. The akh belonged to cardinal terms of ancient Egyptian religion and hence is often found in Egyptian religious texts, as well as in other textual and iconographic sources. Its basic meaning was related to effectiveness and reciprocal relationship that crossed the borderlines between different spheres.

NBI at Boujdour

Although young NBI records are not extremely rare in the Atlantic Sahara, specially in Boujdor, every single sighting is very important to understand the behaviour of the species.

Recently, Hugues Dufourny reported to http://www.go-south.org/ the sighting of one sub-adult bald ibis at Boujdour, on December 27th.

On the pictures (©Véronique Buchet) we can observe the kind of habitat on the coast in the region, while the dominant area is much more drier. Constant wind makes plastics fly and they stay on the browses.

In the same site web, Runar Jåbekk cited two other NBI at Boujdour in february 2012.

Every single sighting of Northern Bald Ibis outside Tamri and Souss-Massa area is extremely important to improve the knowledge on the species and improve its status. Please, share your redords with us. 

2012 breeding season results

2012 breeding season finished with uneven results in Souss Massa National Park and Tamri regarding breeding success.

Monitoring takes place thanks to the seven wardens that are permanently on place, supported by Prince Albert II of Monaco Foundation.

While in the protected area results were quite usual, similar to previous year, in Tamri we have recorded a failure on breeding success. Thus, in Souss-Massa 34 pairs nested (two less than in 2011) and 95 chicks hatched (one less that in 2011). 56 of them fledged (vs. 79 in 2011), thus survival was lower that last year (1,03 against 1,3). Nevertheless, at Tamri there were less pairs formed, 43 vs. 51 during the previous season. This should not be a problem, but just 11 of them lay eggs. None of them finished the incubation period.

It is not clear what the causes of the failure are, but, comparing this situation with previous years, we found that results were also bad in 2008. That year, there were 55 fledgings in Souss Massa and two in Tamri.

Although many factors could affect breeding, we found that 2008 was also a dry year; the first trimester had just 21 mm being the average for that period 99 mm. In 2012 rainfall was jus 6 mm in that period.